All i can say is WOW HERES 2 THOSE BUTTONS!!!!

[marty]

What a morning !!!Buddy called me last night to come up to his property to hunt this morn because hes got a monster up there and boy was he right.Saw this buck coming down trail hot on a doe threw a few grunts had him at twenty two yds broadside .Wasnt really sure if what i was seeing was real was hoping for another button hahahhaahaha .well all i can say was double lung ran about 35 yds and piled up :bow: age determined looks like a 5yr old buck 16pts 2 drops in the back dressed out at234lbs.Hey looks like all those little managed deer paid off.saw 3 other bucks this morn some real nice shooters :razz:

[what the buck]

NICE BUCK. does your buddy need some more help hunting on his property. lol

[woodghost]

Very nice!!! tuff to stop smiling for the pix when he's that nice!!!

[marty]

Thanks guys its amazing that there has been no negative reply:nuts:But anyway its looking like he scoring in the mid 180 gonna wait a few more days and see:thup:

[Jersey Fresh Kill]

sorry about reposting your pic, but those thumbnails are too tedious...

http://i214.photobucket.com/albums/cc101/sjdeerassociation/11150812121.jpg

[marty]

First time posting a pic on this site trying to get more familiar .Thank you .Very much appreciated:thup:

[Gr8ful Deer]

That's beaut right there. Nice buck.

I'll bet you felt a bit better about tagging that one than those button bucks!

CONGRATS !!!

- Gr8ful

[DV1]

That is a great buck, congrats to you. :thup: What county did you take him in?

[sud-z]

Nice slob! I wish pigs were in season in PA atleast 1 week longer. Nice buck.

[EMK]

Pretty ironic:rolleyes:

That is a nice buck.

[ub1243]

if you let them live they get big fast.
great buck, tons of mass.:thup:

[DOC BANDIT]

GREAT DEER MARTY What a great way to fill your buck tag:bow::bow::thup::thup:

[louf]

wowwwwww......what a buck.... congrats on ur trophy deer...thats going to be tough to beat:thup:

[njbowhunter]

Awsome buck I guess you will be entering that deer in the new jersey outstanding deer. If 180 inches doesnt get you in then you atleast get in the 200 lbs club.

[EMK]

I cant wait to see it there, you will be entering it right?

[Blood Trail]

WOW What a BRUISER congrats on a great deer

[vonhess]

If we keep harvesting bucks like that, the guys in kansas are going to start booking trips to jersey.:D 234 whats the state record for weight? used to be 227 taken in zone 35. Oh Yea, forgot congrats on a beauty. WILL

[grtwhthunter/fisherman]

awsome deer good thing you took the buttons out or he woulda killed them by steppin on them:yahooo::cheers:

[PhilCVG]

We can all go to the Deer Classic and say we know Marty :)

[Bud8Fan]

awesome buck, congrats!

[DV1]

The state record was 240 from Mercer.

[nontyp-hunter]

NICE BUCK!!
Give some details: stand? or ground?, bow type, arrow type, shot placement, tracking. How far did it go. Any signs (rubs scrapes)of this one were you hunted. Did you scout and see this big guy earlier in the season. Any pictures of him earlier in the season.
Congrats on your trophy & Great job.
BK

[phillyfishing]

thats a huge deer..... congrats.. bet your buddy is upset he didn't get em

[SEMIAUTO]

That's a super nice buck , your the man .

[WardMan]

NICE!!! I thinks I'm gonna start to bow hunt. That's an awesome buck!

[HUNTIN-NUT]

Congrats - great buck. Real stud there!

[fishy]

180 will put you at #4 you are one lucky S.O.B and your freind must really like you.

[dblungr]

WOW!! I would fall out of the f@#$% tree if i saw that monster coming at me. More details please?

[Bait Runner]

Congrats on a awesome deer. I thought my 163 inch was going to hold out, but I will be more than glad to stand next to you with that stud. Enjoy the moment and buy your buddy and his wife a great christmas present. WOW what a Stud plus a 200 pound patch to boot.

[Bait Runner]

Just a reminder!!!!!! Make sure your weight of your deer is from a certified scale. If not, before you have him cut up, get him weighed on a certified scale for your 200 pound club entry in the classic. Nice Job.

[jswany04]

If you killed that deer then congratulations because it is a fine deer. But remember deer dont get that big if they are shot when they are button bucks. If you did not shot that deer then you are a coward for posting the picture of another hunters kill and posting it as your own. But let me say that if in fact that is your deer then congrats on a fine animal.

["String Music"]

If you did not shot that deer then you are a coward for posting the picture of another hunters kill and posting it as your own.[/quote]
Why would you even bring that up? Do you have some info to something that we dont?

[jonny one shot]

nice buck :bow:you the man

[EMK]

If you did not shot that deer then you are a coward for posting the picture of another hunters kill and posting it as your own.
Why would you even bring that up? Do you have some info to something that we dont?[/quote]



stemming from another post. He shot three buttons, said he wasn't to proud of it, didn't even want to put a pick up. Says he shot it only because he had a shot. But is looking for the racks. Got slammed.

Then the very next day WAALAA, he shoots a rack. Ironic?

["String Music"]

Oh!.....I See now!!!!!!:naughty:

[yobuck09]

Is the time correct in that photo, on 11-28-2008 at 5:21 around my way it was dark out?

[vonhess]

I thought the same thing, he was getting hammered for his post, I think it was (great morning). Where he shot a button buck, and then the next day he shoots a buck of 2 lifetimes:eek:. I thought either he is the luckiest S.O.B, or full of it, which one is it marty?

[PhilCVG]

The photo has no time stamp. The time stamp you are seeing is when it was uploaded to the site.

[EMK]

Where he shot a button buck

Not just one, three. Which there is nothing wrong with, only because its legal.

[shakey]

1 thing for sure that was awesome animal. Congrats

[Darrin Greene]

Already on our way to nobody posting anything I see...

Seems firmiliar :huh: :naughty:

Cut the guy a friggin break already will ya...

[KILBO]

It's always the same story when someone shoots a great deer.
1. As far as I'm concerned shoot all the button bucks you want because I'm a meat hunter myself but I do love a great rack for the wall.
2. I don't know about where you hunt but trying to manage deer where I am is next to impossible. So if I pass up a deer that may be a great buck next year may mean he ends up being killed by another guy who will shoot anything with fur. ( witnessed guys shooting at a group of does during the shotgun season so I know they don't care if it should be a buck or not:eek: ) As a side note to this they were not guys that I hunt with but a group of people who also hunt where I am.
3. I would only try to manage deer and not shoot button bucks if I had permission to hunt a very large tract of land ( not a lot of that in NJ ) that I knew the deer would make it thru to next year.
4. Now if that isn't your deer in the photo then shame on you. But if it is true then I will say congrats to on a great deer and don't listen to all the negative feedback because you know the truth and thats all that matters.
Good luck in the future.


BRIAN

[jswany04]

If it was true he would be back on this post. But he ironically disappeared. I think he is a fraud. And i will continue thinking that until he can prove otherwise.

[njbowhunter]

I dont know marty so I can not judge him. The one thing I do find funny is no one is talking about this deer. On the other sights I visit you always hear about big deer harvested. Why has no one heared of this massive 180 inch deer.

[mccool]

hey guys you might want to back off marty if he is telling the truth you are just making yourselves look bad he says in his last post on his other thread that he is in cabo marlin fishing for the next few weeks if that is true that would explain why this is not the talk of the town we will see how this plays out soon enough for now give him credit for shooting a buck bigger than most of us will ever see in the wild.

[EMK]

hey guys you might want to back off marty if he is telling the truth you are just making yourselves look bad he says in his last post on his other thread that he is in cabo marlin fishing for the next few weeks if that is true that would explain why this is not the talk of the town we will see how this plays out soon enough for now give him credit for shooting a buck bigger than most of us will ever see in the wild.


That gives him an excuse not to reply to the posts, the guy is full of s#it and thats that. If by chance he did kill this one good for him but I think hes a slob hunter for killing "another " BB just because it was there to shoot, and then say it nothing to be proud of. If I am ever desperate enough to go back to shooting 40lb'ers I would post pics and be proud of anything I shot.

Don't bitch that there are no bucks then condone someone that shoots a dink BB.

[louf]

EMK, ur the type of person that make people stop replying.....u probably questioned the 78 pound striper back in the day that made mcreyonlds say screw this and disappear....what is ur problem.....do u get jealous if someone catches one bigger than u.....if i was marty, i would say ffff u and leave this site for all the bullshit u gave him about his LEGAL buttonbucks and his trophy deer.

[EMK]

I said if he did shoot it good for him .

go back and see where i said theres nothing wrong with shooting a BB because its legal, I don't because I don't believe in it but I sure as hell would be proud of what ever I shot.

Thats where this started, do some more reading.

Trust me I could care less if someone shot a P&Y out of my stand, obviously I either wasn't there or couldn't get the job done.

Only thing worse than a guy shooting deer just because it was there and not be proud of it is someone running his mouth about something he obviously knows nothing about.

[louf]

ur biography says it all.... and second ur opinion

[EMK]

Everyones entitled to their opinion.:thup: And right back at you Jr..

[Ron Redington]

OUCH!

Marty, I'm sorry I didn't get to this sooner. My apologies.:o Congratulations on your deer :thup:

- To all the doubters...I'm on board with your thought process here. The guy shoots a couple button bucks, get's razzed a bit, then comes back with a monster :please: ...I hear ya. BUT I can't sit here and let ya beat the guy up over it. If I do, #1 it's not fair to Marty, who until proven otherwise was simply contributing to the community via his report (something we wish everyone would do) #2 It's gonna discourage others from posting reports in the future. I'm sure I don't have to spell out what happens if people stop posting reports :(

Going forward we're not going to allow disruption of members reports. There's not one good thing that comes from it. I hope everyone understands :)

[fishy]

that is one hell of a deer. I don't know him from a hole in the ground but i certainly won't take cheap shots at him for doing what i could only wished to achieved this season. Envy is a sin

[mccool]

ur biography says it all.... and second ur opinion
I third that! emk dont go away mad just go away:nuts:

[stonefly]

nevermind...i get it now, it was a joke...it's a picture of the button buck with an overlay...and you all fell for it, suckas

[Ron Redington]

Sorry Marty but apparently some folks missed the part where I mentioned we weren't gonna tolerate reports being disrupted :rolleyes: I gotta lock this one down :thdown: